Search
Choose a style
Dark
Light
Time to read: 6 min

Can gambling learn from alcohol, crypto and trading on consumer protection?

lightbulb with spakrs
Image: IRA_EVVA / Shutterstock

The gambling sector is going through a challenge in perception and communications with external stakeholders as pressure grows on regulators and governments to clamp down on the sector in jurisdictions from Brazil to the UK and many places in between. 

While gambling is a well-known vice and public backlash should be expected to a certain extent, alcohol and tobacco appear to be much more socially accepted.

This was the topic of one of SBC Insight’s latest webinar sessions, titled “Beyond Gambling: What Other Industries Can Teach Us About Consumer Protection?”.

The session was part of SBC’s Digital Player Protection Day and inspired by the fifth edition of the International Player Safety Index, From Compliance To Care: What iGaming Can Learn from Other Regulated Industries About Player Education, Support and Wellbeing?

Gambling could take 100 years to be socially acceptable

One of the panelists, Thees Buschmann, Senior Consultant at Chevron Group, outlined that from his experiences growing up in Germany, gambling is more of a taboo subject than other sectors such as alcohol or financial trading services.

Buschmann explained: “No one is ashamed of drinking. When you say you are a drinker, this doesn’t mean you are an alcoholic. No one says they gamble. But if they confess, [there is a perception] they have been a problem gambler. In most Western European countries, gambling is still something that is seen as somehow dodgy or dirty. No one will confess that they do, or no one would say they do it unless it’s a confession.”

Asked by moderator Simon Westbury – chair of 1xCare’s advisory committee – why this is the case, Buschmann added that it is because attitudes have been passed down the generations. 

“This is something we inherited from our parents, from our grandparents; from a cultural perspective, gambling is something that is somehow received badly, in a way a little bit better than prostitution, but not a lot.

“With drinking, it’s completely different. It is very important that consumer protection in gambling starts with the awareness of the players. I don’t really see how this public perception can be changed in gambling within one, two or three generations. Most people in Germany, the Netherlands or Sweden will think about gamblers the same way they think today. Everything we are doing to protect players must incorporate this.”

This perspective helped to shape the conversation around how gambling can take learnings from other high-risk industries about how they protect consumers. 

Alcohol industry provides strong platform for consumer protection

Ashley Cahill is the co-founder of Fiore-Cahill Advisory, a new consultancy for iGaming operators on player protection. An ex-FanDuel player protection lead, Cahill was previously involved in the alcohol industry. She worked for Anheuser-Busch on safer drinking policies, where she helped to shape messaging with consumers in the US. 

“I think some of the biggest lessons are really around the importance of sustained investment when it comes to a lot of the player protection, marketing and public affairs strategies,” she said.

One example she cited was the creation of the ‘designated driver’ idea that a friendship group would nominate one person to remain sober and drive each time they go out drinking. The idea was written into more than 100 episodes of television programming which helped spread the message far better than any public service announcement. 

Importantly, she outlined, was that the entire industry bought into the campaign. 

“The beer industry did work together. Leadership from Anheuser-Busch, the market leader at the time — and as everyone knows, often the market leaders in a lot of ways have the most to lose and the most to benefit from really raising the bar, since when they become synonymous with the industry, they can even pay for the sins of others.

“The spirits industry also banded together through organisations called the Century Council, later responsibility.org. So there definitely was coordination on those fronts. Less together between spirits and beer, but I think they did a good job banding together in the 80s, 90s, and 2000s to raise standards and really establish industry codes to address concerns around advertising.”

The lesson for iGaming is that the sector must explore ways of going beyond just public service announcements to try to normalise behaviours that change attitudes amongst consumers in a more organic way.

Financial services and crypto exchanges pave a new way

Piotr Lisak, COO at Q Securities S.A., outlined his experience from the financial services and cryptocurrency exchange industries. He explained that various pieces of legislation introduced in recent years in the European Union such as the Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation have dictated how providers should adopt investor protections. 

The parallels with iGaming are clear here; regulators are continually exploring ways of mandating protections into laws and regulations.

Lisak explained how regulations mandate that providers help limit the risk for retail investors. 

“I think it’s still 70-80% of retail investors who go into the derivatives markets and lose money,” he said. “Even if you compare that to gambling, when you have regulated gambling and return to player rates more stable over a certain amount of time, it’s quite striking that actually investing in financial instruments can still make you worse off than than long term play on slots for instance, which have returned to player at certain higher percentages.”

Measures such as loss limits and deposit limits evoke a similar idea of protection in a gambling sense, but Westbury quizzed whether some of these measures are a little too intrusive or go into the realm of performative compliance rather than genuine consumer protection.

Lisak responded by outlining the purposes of regulation like MiCA and MiFID II — to protect consumers in the wake of the 2008 financial crisis.

“As we know, the financial crisis lessons were not only about investor protections, but also protections of the wider financial system. I think when drafting these regulations, the legislators were considering both angles — covering the stability of the financial system while at the same time implementing these investor protection measures.”

‘From Compliance To Care: What iGaming Can Learn from Other Regulated Industries About Player Education, Support and Wellbeing?’ goes into depth about operator and consumer attitudes towards consumer protection across a number of high-risk industries including financial services and cryptocurrencies. 

These industries were highlighted for their ability to use questionnaires to gauge customer risk appetite, provide upfront messaging about platform risks, and offer inspiration for how online gambling could adapt similar practices.

To learn more about how iGaming can learn from other high-risk industries regarding consumer protection, download the full report here. You can also watch the full webinar by registering on SBC Connect.

Subscribe to our newsletter