Search
Choose a style
Dark
Light
Time to read: 10 min

Amelco: sportsbooks don’t need to limit winning punters to protect profit

restriction
Image: Contributor PAS_Vecto / Shutterstock

A common complaint that punters have with licensed sportsbooks is that as soon as they begin a winning streak, they are banned or severely limited in their stakes. The practice is perhaps understandable from operators; if they identify customers who are consistently beating the house, then an operator looking to manage their risk would limit that customer. 

But is it always necessary? 

Harry Gasper, Amelco’s Trading Performance Lead argues that operators don’t always need to resort to restricting bettors to manage risk. He touches on Amelco’s trading strategy and offers insights into what operators are thinking when limiting punters and offers an alternative path.

SBC News Amelco: sportsbooks don’t need to limit winning punters to protect profit

Most UK and European books have stopped trading altogether—they just copy Pinnacle or the exchanges and ban anyone who beats the closing line. Why has the industry become so lazy?

Saying the industry has become ‘lazy’ oversimplifies a complex issue, though there is fair criticism underneath. With most bookmakers offering more market types and greater variety than ever before, pricing them all in-house can seem expensive and impossibly time-consuming. Copying reputable, sharp, liquid pricing sources while restricting anyone who beats the closing line is understandably an efficient business model.

I believe an element of laziness comes into play when the first response to any sign of informed betting is immediate, blanket restrictions. If a customer is constantly taking a price before it shortens, this should prompt questions about your pricing, how quickly you react to market movements and whether your liability controls are appropriate for that market or event. Heavily restricting the account solves the immediate issue of laying further ‘bad’ bets from that customer, but that customer may reappear next time your price is out, using a different account – and at that point, you are starting from scratch with your profiling again.

There is also an incentive issue. If a trading desk is judged primarily on short-term margin, it can become very adept at avoiding business for fear of being perceived as underperforming. At Amelco, our view is that trading should involve understanding which risks are worth taking, supported by the tools, judgement and industry knowledge to manage them.

Slamming the door on every punter with positive CLV looks safe on paper, but what is the real commercial cost of gutting your liquidity and reputation?

Immediately and significantly limiting every punter with positive CLV is a prime example of short-term thinking. While the immediate benefit of restricting an account is clear, the commercial cost of getting that decision wrong is far less visible. You have paid to acquire that customer and a knee-jerk blanket restriction across all sports and markets can drive away all their future business based on a perceived edge that may exist in only one sport or market.

A genuine, recreational punter does not necessarily know whether they are beating the closing line, so it is perfectly possible to see one with positive CLV over an insufficient sample size. This is why context matters: how consistent is this apparent edge? What does the rest of the customer’s activity look like? Is the sample size statistically sufficient? It is perfectly feasible for a customer to be price-sensitive to a degree yet still be a good customer for the book across their betting portfolio.

Slamming the door every time a punter appears to be beating the closing line also has a wider cost to confidence in the sportsbook product you are offering. If customers believe that taking a good price or having a winning run will get them shown the door, that weakens the reason to stay and recommend you to others in a more competitive market than ever. The objective should be sustainable profit; a higher margin percentage on a shrinking customer base is not automatically a healthier sportsbook.

We argue that sportsbooks don’t need to ban sharp or semi-sharp players to turn a profit. How does Amelco actually make money off smart action instead of running scared of it?

The starting point is to understand where a customer’s edge comes from – this is where the right combination of trader knowledge and technology is vital. A punter with a particular edge in one sport, competition, market, or bet type should not automatically be treated the same across everything a bookmaker offers; that understanding lets us make more considered decisions about pricing and limits.

Informed action provides useful information. If a customer consistently identifies a mispriced bet type or situation, accepting a controlled amount of that business can help improve the price we offer and prevent the accumulation of poor liabilities at odds that don’t reflect the true price. The main challenge, however, is acting on that information efficiently and effectively.

We combine decades of trading expertise with the right tools and technology to manage prices and liabilities around each operator’s risk appetite. That gives us a much healthier (and more profitable!) balance than simply leaving an account fully unrestricted or restricted to pennies.

There will still naturally be types of business that it will never make commercial sense to operate – there is a big difference between a blatantly obvious arb and a shrewd bet. The overall aim is to retain as much worthwhile sharp business as possible, whilst effectively managing the bespoke risk a customer presents.

What does dynamic liability management look like in practice when sharp money hits a market? How do automated updates react faster than a human trader?

Dynamically managing liabilities and risk centres on constantly and rapidly reassessing your liability position and risk appetite whilst considering all available factors. Whilst it may seem at first that the laid stake or liability amount is the most important indicator, a smaller bet from a known mark with a proven, statistically significant edge can be a more useful indicator than a much larger bet from another customer. The liability you are willing to lay should be constantly reassessed and changed in line with market conditions, your existing position and the context of the business you have already seen.

Informed money may mean your odds are wrong, but a large liability can simply mean you have reached your risk tolerance for that outcome; how you respond to each situation varies. If you have a position where your exposure is building, the response could involve cutting the price, reducing customer-level market limits, or escalating the position for review by a more senior trader.

Automated liability controls can evaluate all relevant factors and take a predefined action if the criteria are met, significantly faster than a human trader could manually assess the situation and decide on the appropriate response, thereby preventing further undesired exposure from building. The human touch will always be necessary to set the relevant parameters, review exceptions and decide whether an exception should be handled differently, but combining this with technology and automation allows rapid action to be taken in line with the requirements and expectations of each of our operators.

Most operators just mirror the exchange to cut costs, how do Amelco’s pricing models give them an edge without blowing up their trading budget?

External pricing sources such as betting exchanges are a useful reference as to where the market is trending, but they don’t give you a concrete answer on how to trade your own book. Every operator, sharp or soft, has its own unique customer base, betting patterns, and risk appetite. Whilst the exchange, in theory, provides the best of all worlds, the same starting price does not necessarily call for the same trading decisions.

At Amelco, we bring together pricing inputs with trading expertise, internal modelling and configurable controls and parameters, allowing our operators to manage margins and exposure in line with their business objectives. The edge comes from how effectively those factors combine, including recognising when a price needs attention and where there is room to accept more business.

Automation and technology make that approach to bookmaking scalable. Handling routine updates and systematic monitoring lets specialist traders focus on exceptions and opportunities where their judgement adds the most value, drawing on years of accumulated wisdom and industry knowledge. The days when you need a human trader physically managing every price are clearly behind us. However, you do need someone to take ownership of the overall pricing strategy – this approach represents the best of both worlds. Blindly following external pricing sources without a tailored, bespoke approach to bookmaking is no way to build and maintain a successful book.

What happens to turnover and retention when a sportsbook keeps its doors open to genuine bettors instead of restricting accounts after three bets?

There is a real reputational risk in being perceived as an operator that will blindly restrict a customer at the first sign of a positive P/L. Whilst this will, of course, ward off some undesirable business, it will also discourage valuable warm pricing indicators and marks, as well as your run-of-the-mill recreational customer, who will inevitably go on a winning run eventually. With customer acquisition costs a significant consideration, having a reputation for being willing to take a bet helps build loyalty beyond introductory offers like welcome free bets.

As previously discussed, a genuine, recreational punter may not know whether they are beating the closing price, and it is perfectly feasible that they will over a limited sample size. Making a harsh and premature judgement risks driving away potentially valuable customers based on a false positive caused by overvaluing insufficient data. Rather, it is more efficient to apply proportionate controls that enable you to understand that customer’s business while managing your exposure.

The real test comes from a commercial perspective – does retained activity contribute to sustainable profit? It is important to assess turnover and retention alongside expected margin over the longer term to inform and shape your risk strategy. A higher turnover isn’t inherently more valuable, but unnecessarily rejecting worthwhile business puts a ceiling on growth.

For operators stuck in the “restrict anyone beating CLV” cycle, what is the first thing they need to fix on their trading desk?

For me, the key point here is making sure you have the right people in the right positions and that you are making full use of the technology available to you.

Start by reviewing real examples of customers you are restricting and the quantifiable factors behind those decisions. Are your traders overreacting to short-term volatility, or making rushed, poorly informed decisions as soon as a customer is in the red for the book? Make sure you fully leverage the experience and wisdom of the people on your trading desk, and that they have access to the right technology and analytical tools to make data-driven decisions rather than emotive ones.

Are you proactively identifying where these customers’ edges come from and using that to inform your trading strategy, or are you playing the ‘whack-a-mole’ game of instantly restricting accounts as soon as they appear?

Whilst the latter may seem easier and more efficient in the short run, the former is how you build a sustainable book. It is also vital to ensure that the objectives set for the trading desk reflect this and that metrics are based on long-term strategy, not short-term outcomes.

Subscribe to our newsletter