Search
Choose a style
Dark
Light
Time to read: 2 min

No clarity yet on Malta’s Bill 55 EU law compliance

A court hammer with the EU flag in the background
Lukas Gojda/Shutterstock

The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has refused to rule on the compatibility of Malta’s Bill 55 with EU law.

A legal battle has been brewing over the last three years, involving Austrian player losses that were incurred on gambling platforms licensed in Malta, but operating in a grey area in DACH jurisdictions.

In 2023, Malta introduced a major legislative change to its Gambling Act with Bill 55. The law was intended to create a shield for the island country’s licensed gambling operators, protecting them from lawsuits originating in foreign European courts.

At the core of the legislation lays the European free trade principle, which Malta argues protects its domesticated businesses’ rights to have unobstructed access to other EU members’ markets.

This caused significant friction with Austria further down the line. Legal cases against Maltese operators were starting to ramp up as local players sought to recoup losses accumulated on gambling platforms not part of Austria’s licensed gambling regime.

Bill 55 question dropped by CJEU

One company, Spielerschutz Sigma (Player Protection Sigma), has been directly involved by paying some of the upfront legal costs of Austrian gamblers trying to win back their money.

Shortly following Malta’s Bill 55 introduction, Spielerschutz entered a partnership with an Austrian legal entity to request an assessment of the validity of the new Maltese law.

The received report was allegedly adamant in its conclusion that Bill 55 contradicts established EU law practices, and therefore cannot be used by Maltese courts.

This gave Spielerschutz the green light to continue with its player support services, now backed by the newly-acquired legal assessment. However, Maltese courts then used Bill 55 to subsequently reject the claims and attempted enforcement.

Spielerschutz then filed a legal complaint with the Commercial Court of Vienna against the very same law practice it used for the Bill’s assessment, seeking financial compensation based on professional negligence.

The Vienna Court referred the case to the CJEU in 2024 and asked the Court of Justice whether Bill 55 is actually EU compliant.

However, the CJEU has now returned the case back to Vienna without a ruling, after it concluded the Bill 55 question is not relevant to the resolution of the legal dispute.

But with players in Germany also currently seeking compensation from Maltese operators, the Bill 55 question remains far from settled.

Subscribe to our newsletter